STGSILVER TAX GROUP
800-778-2741
Open 24 hrs / 7 Days A Week
Real Tax Attorneys For Real Tax Issues

Fast Action. Proven Results.

START WITH A FREE CASE EVALUATION

MLB cries foul on change to tax code

Like a perfect change-up, the new tax code has Major League Baseball wrong-footed and looking foolish. The change did not target professional sports, specifically, but it has the potential to cause a major shift in the way teams do business. The calculus behind when or whether to make a trade could be altered, depending on how leagues, the IRS and Congress respond.

Like-kind exchange

The issue involves something known as the like-kind exchange. These exchanges were designed to allow businesses and individuals to trade assets for other, similar assets. Some examples include the exchange of one piece of farmland for another, or one fleet of moving vans for another. If no other cash, debt relief or unrelated property is involved, the two assets could be exchanged without any tax consequences. In the world of sports, teams could trade players (or more accurately their contracts), without tax implications because the assets traded were considered of like-kind.

A whole new ballgame

The new tax code made a small, but intentional change designed to limit like-kind exchanges. These exchanges are now limited to swaps of real property, meaning real estate and land interests. Player contracts are not real property, under the tax code, so teams making trades could face capital gains tax liability depending on how the trades are viewed. 

As is often the case, small changes in tax laws cause big problems for the people and companies who must obey them. Baseball trades are rarely equal in terms of the salary exchanged. Typical trades involve highly compensated veterans being swapped for multiple young players making minor league money. While the young players could be considered more "valuable" by the team acquiring them, they are certainly less well compensated.

Some contracts are considered nearly untradeable due to injuries or poor performance by the player. Teams taking on these contracts expect to receive other assets to compensate them for having to pay the player in question. If the team taking on such a contract would also have to pay the IRS for the extra "value" received in the trade, it would become even harder to move these veterans. 

The batting eye of the beholder

In baseball, assigning value to players is an almost impossible exercise. Playing ability combines with age, salary, the quality of the team, the player's position and countless other factors to make up that players true value. This value is obviously unique to the team. The teams in playoff contention value current contributors more than future prospects. Any method of assigning a dollar value to every transaction is bound to lead to results that don't jibe with the assessments of the participating teams. 

The IRS and Congress has so far made no mention of how sports teams will comply with the new rules. The uncertainty should factor into team thinking as the trade deadline draws near. The ripple effects of the new code will likely last for some time.

Source: The New York Times, "A Curveball From the New Tax Law: It Makes Baseball Trades Harder," by Jim Tankersley, 19 March 2018

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

When you hire us, we can help: you:

  • Obtain emergency relief from IRS actions
  • Stop the IRS from garnishing your wages
  • Prevent levees from being placed on your bank accounts
  • Keep tax payments and penalties from spiraling out of control

Phone Answered 24/7

We are always available to answer your questions and put your mind at ease.

Call us today at
800-778-2741 for a free initial consultation

Competitive Pricing

We offer flat fees that fit your needs and your budget.

Read Our Pricing FAQ

What Past Clients Say About Us

I know I won't be getting those frightening letters anymore thanks to Chad Silver - such a weight off my mind!” - A. Gould, Ohio

Read More Testimonials

A Real History of Success

IRS debt of $682,437, Attorney Silver and his team negotiated the Debt down to zero.

View More Results

You Can Fight The IRS And Win. We Can Help.

No matter where you are in the process, we can help you make the best of your situation. Call us toll free at 800-778-2741 for a free case evaluation.

Get A Free Consultation »
PRACTICING TAX LAW NATIONWIDE

Privacy Policy | Business Development Solutions by FindLaw, part of Thomson Reuters.

Back To Top